Thread Rating:
Could the Universe Be Fundamentally Discrete?
#1
Could the Universe Be Fundamentally Discrete?

We usually think of space and time as smooth and continuous.

You can always zoom in further.
You can always divide distances again.

But some theories suggest this intuition may be wrong.

What if the universe is fundamentally discrete?



What “discrete” would mean

A discrete universe would have:
• a smallest unit of space
• a smallest unit of time
• no meaning to distances smaller than these limits

Beyond a certain scale, “in-between” would simply not exist.



Hints from quantum physics

Quantum mechanics already introduces discreteness:
• energy levels in atoms are quantized
• angular momentum comes in fixed units
• photons carry energy in packets

This raises a natural question:
If energy is discrete, why not spacetime itself?



Planck scales

From known constants, physics defines natural limits:

• Planck length ≈ 1.6 × 10⁻³⁵ m
• Planck time ≈ 5.4 × 10⁻⁴⁴ s

Below these scales:
• quantum gravity effects dominate
• classical spacetime descriptions break down

These are not proven “pixels” — but they mark where current theories fail.



Discrete spacetime models

Some speculative approaches propose:
• spacetime made of tiny discrete elements
• geometry emerging from networks or graphs
• time advancing in fundamental steps

Examples include:
• loop-based approaches
• causal-set models
• lattice formulations

None are experimentally confirmed.



What discreteness would change

If spacetime is discrete:
• infinities might disappear from physics
• gravity could become quantizable
• the universe would have a natural resolution limit

But it would also challenge:
• Lorentz invariance
• smooth geometry
• classical notions of motion



Why this is hard to test

Planck-scale effects are extraordinarily small.

Even the most powerful experiments:
• cannot probe distances remotely close
• cannot access Planck energies

Any signal would be indirect and subtle.



Continuous vs discrete may be a false choice

It is possible that:
• spacetime is discrete at small scales
• but appears continuous at large scales

Much like matter:
• made of atoms
• but experienced as smooth



Open question

Is spacetime fundamentally continuous, discrete, or something else entirely?

The answer may require a theory that has not yet been discovered.
Reply
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)